Vinu:  During credit appraisal, we hear the term "forensic review" quite often. What does it actually mean?

Manu: A forensic review is a deeper examination of a borrower's financial statements and business records to identify inconsistencies, unusual transactions, possible fund diversion, or signs of financial manipulation that may not be visible through routine ratio analysis.

Vinu: So it's different from normal financial analysis?

Manu: Exactly. Financial analysis tells us how the business is performing. A forensic review asks whether the reported numbers truly reflect the underlying business.

Vinu: What should a credit officer examine first?

Manu: Start with consistency. Compare the Balance Sheet, Profit & Loss Account, Cash Flow Statement, GST returns, Income Tax Returns, bank statements, and audited financial statements to ensure they tell the same story.

Vinu: Why is consistency so important?

Manu: Because genuine businesses usually have logical consistency across financial records. Major unexplained differences deserve further investigation.

Vinu: What are some common warning signs?

Manu: Sudden spikes in sales, unusually high profits, large year-end transactions, rapidly increasing receivables, unexplained loans and advances, or significant related-party transactions.

Vinu: Can you explain with an example?

Manu: Suppose annual sales increase from ₹8 crore to ₹18 crore in one year, but debtors also rise sharply and operating cash flow remains weak. The sales growth may require closer verification.

Vinu: Why are receivables closely examined?

Manu: Because profits are recorded when sales occur, but cash is received only when customers pay. Continuously rising receivables may indicate delayed collections or even questionable sales.

Vinu: What should we look for in inventory?

Manu: Excessive inventory growth compared to sales, slow-moving stock, or inventory increasing every year without corresponding turnover may indicate operational issues or possible overstatement.

Vinu: Are related-party transactions part of a forensic review?

Manu: Definitely. Large loans, advances, purchases, or sales involving promoter-controlled entities should always be examined for commercial justification.

Vinu: How useful are bank statements during forensic analysis?

Manu: Extremely useful. They help verify whether reported business activity matches actual fund flows and whether there are unusual transfers, frequent cash withdrawals, or round-tripping of funds.

Vinu: What is round-tripping?

Manu: It refers to funds moving through multiple accounts or entities and eventually returning to the original business, sometimes to create an artificial appearance of business activity or liquidity.

Vinu: Should bankers review statutory compliance as well?

Manu: Yes. Delays in GST payments, Income Tax dues, PF, ESI, or other statutory liabilities may indicate financial stress or weak governance.

Vinu: Can cash flow analysis reveal hidden problems?

Manu: Absolutely. A company reporting consistent profits but generating poor operating cash flow year after year deserves closer scrutiny.

Vinu: What role do Notes to Accounts play?

Manu: They often disclose contingent liabilities, guarantees, related-party transactions, accounting policy changes, legal disputes, and other important information that may not be obvious from the financial statements alone.

Vinu: Should bankers compare multiple years instead of only one?

Manu: Certainly. Trend analysis over three to five years often reveals patterns that a single year's financial statements cannot.

Vinu: How important is management interaction during a forensic review?

Manu: Very important. Credit officers should seek explanations for unusual financial movements and assess whether management's responses are logical, consistent, and supported by evidence.

Vinu: Can one red flag lead to rejection of the proposal?

Manu: Not necessarily. One issue may have a genuine explanation. However, multiple unexplained warning signals together significantly increase credit risk.

Vinu: What is the biggest mistake credit officers make during forensic reviews?

Manu: They focus only on financial ratios and overlook the quality, credibility, and consistency of the underlying financial information.

Vinu: If you had to summarize a forensic review in one sentence, what would you say?

Manu: A forensic review goes beyond the numbers to determine whether the borrower's financial statements present a true, transparent, and reliable picture of the business.

To learn more about Banking & Financial related topics

We invite you to join our Diamond Membership
Check - https://courses.carajaclasses.com/courses/Diamond-Membership-6305fad1e4b0cccc82d610be
For Special Discount on Diamond Membership 
Connect with us  - https://wa.me/919025100249?text=DLM